Resources

Giving generously is good. Giving wisely helps ensure your donation reaches the people, programs, and causes you intended to support.

In this day and age, donors face real risks when giving to the wrong entity. Fraudulent appeals, look-alike organizations, pressure tactics, poorly managed nonprofits, and unclear online fundraising platforms can divert charitable dollars away from their intended purpose. Giving remains one of the most meaningful ways to help others, but it should be paired with reasonable due diligence.

A cautious donor does not stop giving; a cautious donor gives with care. Before contributing, donors should verify that the organization is legitimate, properly registered where required, transparent about its finances, and a good custodian of donated funds. A reputable charitable nonprofit should be able to explain its mission, disclose how donations are used, and demonstrate that a substantial portion of its resources supports program services rather than excessive fundraising or administrative costs.

Donation Due Diligence Tips

1. Confirm registration and filing status. Charities and professional fundraisers may be required to register with state charity regulators and file annual financial reports. Before donating, confirm that the charity is registered, active, and current with applicable reporting requirements. Registration alone does not mean a government agency endorses the organization, but failure to register or file required reports can be a warning sign.
2. Give to organizations you know, trust, and can verify. Research the charity’s mission, leadership, public filings, and financial records before giving. Review whether the organization spends a meaningful share of its resources on programs that directly support its stated charitable purpose, rather than using too much of each dollar for fundraising, management, or unrelated expenses.
3. Ask for written information. A reputable nonprofit should be willing to provide written materials describing its programs, finances, legal name, mailing address, nonprofit status, and how donated funds will be used. If the organization avoids basic questions or refuses to provide documentation, consider that a reason to pause.
4. Do not give under pressure. Be cautious with phone calls, text messages, emails, or in-person solicitations that demand an immediate donation. Ask who is calling, whether the caller is a paid fundraiser, which charity will benefit, and what percentage of your donation will reach the charity. If the answers are vague, inconsistent, or aggressive, do not donate through that solicitation.
5. Be especially careful after disasters or tragedies. Scammers often exploit emergencies because donors want to help quickly. New organizations may also lack the infrastructure, experience, and relationships needed to deliver aid effectively. Even during a crisis, take a few minutes to verify the charity before donating.
6. Watch for similar-sounding names. Fraudulent or questionable groups may use names, logos, or web addresses that closely resemble established charities. Verify the exact legal name, website, and Employer Identification Number before giving, especially when the solicitation comes through social media, email, text, or a third-party platform.
7. Understand tax-exempt versus tax-deductible. Not every nonprofit is eligible to receive tax-deductible charitable contributions. A Tax ID number or receipt alone does not prove that a gift is deductible. Donors who care about deductibility should verify whether the organization is recognized as eligible to receive tax-deductible contributions and should retain proper records for tax purposes.
8. Consider the true cost of gifts, events, and merchandise. Premiums, gala tickets, merchandise, and promotional items reduce the portion of your payment that may support the charitable mission. If a charity claims that “100% of proceeds” will benefit a cause, ask whether that means gross sales, net proceeds after costs, or some other calculation. There is a big difference.
9. Protect your personal and financial information. Do not provide Social Security numbers, bank information, credit card information, or other sensitive data to an unfamiliar solicitor. Donate directly through a verified charity website or another secure method and review the charity’s privacy policy before sharing contact information.
10. Report suspected fraud or mismanagement. If a fundraiser uses abusive, coercive, or misleading tactics, or if you suspect charitable assets are being diverted or misused, report the concern to the appropriate state charity regulator, consumer protection agency, or law enforcement authority.

Online Giving Tips

Online giving can be convenient, but it also creates opportunities for confusion and fraud. Before donating through a website, social media post, email, crowdfunding page, or fundraising platform, verify that the platform and the recipient organization are legitimate.

1. Be cautious of look-alike websites. Fraudulent websites may use slightly different spellings, domain names, logos, or layouts to imitate legitimate charities. Type the charity’s web address directly when possible and verify the site before entering payment information.
2. Know how your online donation will be used. A donation made through an online button may support the organization’s general operations rather than a specific program. If you want the gift restricted to a particular purpose, confirm the restriction with the charity and keep written documentation.
3. Control future communications. Review opt-in and opt-out boxes before submitting an online gift. If you do not want future emails, texts, or solicitations, choose the appropriate preference before completing the transaction.
4. Do not click first and investigate later. If you receive an unsolicited email or message from an organization you do not recognize, avoid clicking donation links until you independently verify the charity, the appeal, and the payment destination.
5. Research the charity yourself. Do not assume that a recommendation on social media, a blog, or a fundraising page has been vetted. Confirm the organization’s legal status, public filings, program work, and reputation before giving.
6. Understand platform fees and intermediaries. When donating through a social network or fundraising platform, determine whether fees will be deducted, whether part of the gift goes to the platform, and when the charity will actually receive the funds.

Mobile and Digital Payment Donation Tips

Text-to-give campaigns, QR codes, mobile payment apps, and card readers make donating easy, but donors should still confirm that the payment method is connected to the intended charity and that the transaction amount is accurate.

1. Giving through Text:

• Wireless carriers or platforms may cap donation amounts or limit the frequency of gifts, especially during periods of high giving.
• Funds may not be transferred to the charity until the donor pays the related phone bill or the platform completes processing.
• Check whether normal texting, processing, or platform fees apply to the donation.
• Commit only to an amount you can afford, confirm whether the gift is one-time or recurring, and review bills or receipts for unauthorized repeat charges.

1. Giving through QR Code and the Square Card Reader:

• Anyone can create a QR code or use a card reader. Confirm that the code, payment link, or device was provided or authorized by the charity before completing the transaction.
• When scanning a QR code, verify that the destination website matches the charity’s official website and is not a look-alike or unrelated payment page.
• Keep the receipt and compare it to your credit card, bank, PayPal, or payment-app statement to confirm the amount and recipient.

Donation Bin Tips

Donation bins for clothing and household goods can be helpful, but donors should not assume every bin is operated by a charitable nonprofit. Some bins are operated by for-profit companies that sell donated goods and share only a portion, if any, with a charity.

1. Read the fine print on the bin. The bin should identify who operates it, whether a charity benefits, and whether the operator is a for-profit company or a nonprofit organization.
2. Confirm deductibility and use of proceeds. Call or research the organization identified on the bin to determine whether your donation is tax-deductible and how donated goods or sale proceeds are used.

Final Thoughts

The goal is not to discourage generosity. The goal is to protect it. When donors take time to verify a nonprofit’s credibility, registration, financial transparency, and program spending, they increase the likelihood that their money will be used responsibly and will reach the charitable purpose they intended to support.

These are handy Charity Research sites that you can use.

Written by: GF Joey Musmar, CPA, CVA, ABV, PFS, CFF, Managing Partner at MillerMusmar CPAs

Finally, please contact us at info@millermusmar.cpa or +1-703-437-8877 if you are considering a sizeable charitable donation. MillerMusmar CPAs is proud to serve a wide range of nonprofit organizations, providing audit, tax, accounting, and advisory services that support transparency, compliance, and long-term sustainability. Our nonprofit expertise gives us unique insight into the qualities that help organizations earn and maintain donor confidence.

We can help you evaluate the organization, structure the gift appropriately, consider potential tax benefits, and align the donation with your financial and philanthropic goals.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, investment, or financial advice. Donors should consult their CPA, tax advisor, attorney, or financial advisor before making significant charitable contributions or relying on any tax treatment, deduction, or planning strategy.